Prestige Paving

Prestige Paving is a Plymouth asphalt contractor whose review history, spanning 2018 through this month, is almost entirely driveways, with occasional parking lots and backyard basketball courts mixed in. Google carries the widest read at 4.7★ from 91 ratings, while Angi and HomeAdvisor both show an identical 4.3★ from 37 ratings — the latter two read as mirror listings rather than two independent counts. What repeats across dozens of these reviews is speed and price. Customers describe getting a quote the same day or the next morning and having the job finished within a day or two; several say Josh, the owner, quoted them personally and came in below competing estimates. In a 2023 review, a customer described Prestige regrading a 10,000-square-foot parking lot to eliminate standing puddles; a 2025 review credits the crew with regrading a gravel driveway to stop water from pooling in a garage. A 2024 review notes the crew discovering an old concrete layer under the existing asphalt mid-job and adapting the resurfacing around it. A handful of reviews, spread across 2021, 2023 and as recently as September 2025, describe wheel divots, indentations or cracking showing up in the new pavement within weeks — in the September 2025 case despite being told the driveway would settle once the weather cooled, with the customer reporting ongoing problems since. Basketball courts specifically drew separate complaints from two different customers years apart, both saying the surface came out unlevel; one took the dispute to court over a shortchanged measurement. A 2019 review also describes a signed contract sitting unstarted for weeks with calls going unanswered before the homeowner hired someone else, and a July 2026 review reported a company driver texting and driving dangerously on the road. For a standard driveway repave or seal coat — the bulk of what these reviews describe — the volume of specific praise for quick turnaround and fair pricing is real and consistent across years. For a larger or more custom job like a parking lot regrade or a backyard sport court, it's worth asking exactly how the grading and leveling will be checked before the crew leaves, and getting any settling or callback promise in writing.