Verified record
Priscilla Stolba Real Estate is a family-run residential brokerage on Route 28 in Mashpee, representing buyers and sellers across the Upper Cape — Mashpee, Falmouth, New Seabury, Cotuit and West Barnstable. The firm describes itself as independently owned and operated, run by principal Priscilla Stolba alongside her son, broker Tyler Stolba. Clients who have worked with the firm consistently describe hands-on guidance through buying and selling, praising quick responses by phone, text and email and a deep, longtime familiarity with the local market. Several reviewers describe repeat business across multiple purchases and sales with the same family, and one review credits Priscilla with coordinating a same-family sale and purchase within 24 hours. Another describes her working through zoning and conservation issues on a family home, coordinating outside specialists and stepping back to let Tyler help when she wasn't available. Not every account is positive. A detailed 2025 review alleges Priscilla misrepresented details about a condo's history to a buyer and withheld information from an estate's executor during a sale, and describes being blamed for inspection issues the reviewer attributes to a contractor the firm hired. It's worth asking directly about disclosure practices on estate and probate sales and getting clarity on responsibilities if inspection issues surface after closing. There's also a discrepancy in how long the firm has operated: its own site says 1982, while the Better Business Bureau lists a 2011 start date, so buyers and sellers may want to ask directly about its actual history. The Better Business Bureau gives the business an A+ letter grade, though it is not a BBB-accredited business. The firm suits Upper Cape buyers and sellers who want a small, locally rooted brokerage with a track record of repeat clients, while confirming directly how the one documented dispute was handled.
This is the rare time you want to add extra stars to the review to give Priscilla the credit she deserves!! We have used Priscilla Stolba Real Estate for both buying and selling houses and she gives 100% every time, making each client feel that they are genuinely important to her and she goes out of her way to deliver results. Her many years navigating the real estate industry on the Cape give her the advantage over her competitors.
Long story short, I Purchased a condo that Priscilla listed. On day one, before entering the premises, I asked where the owner had died. She said, assisted living. That was not true, he died in the living room. I only found that out after I moved in. Plus, Priscilla hid details of the transaction from the executor of the will. The beneficiary knew nothing of what was going on, she did not inform him. The home inspection was completed, there were many issues to be addressed. I was blamed for a few of them. Even though the contractor she hired did the damage. Priscilla Stolba is out of her league, she needs to retire, is not reputable nor honorable. I would never believe a word she says. They are all lies! Had I known someone died in the condo I just purchased, well things would have been different!
I truly can't say enough wonderful things about Priscilla. Not only is she an exceptional real estate agent, but she also became a trusted friend throughout the entire process. From day one, she approached our home search with the same care and dedication as if it were her own. Every detail mattered to her—she took the time to understand our needs, guided us thoughtfully through each step, and made sure we always felt supported and informed. What sets her apart is that she wasn’t just focused on closing a deal—she was genuinely invested in helping us find the right home. Her warmth, patience, and honesty were a constant source of comfort during what could have been a stressful time. Even after the purchase was complete, she stayed in touch and continued to offer help, making sure we were settled and happy. Working with her was more than just a transaction—it was a truly personal and positive experience.
I worked with Priscilla Stolba as my buyer’s broker in 2023-2024 to purchase a house in the Mashpee area. She was recommended to me by several friends who had utilized her company in the past. Priscilla quickly became a friend with her humor and honest home appraisals. I found Priscilla to possess a deep understanding of the local real estate market. As a long-time local resident, she was knowledgeable about the area, home builders, and house histories. She gave valuable advice without being overbearing as well as kept me informed of potential houses coming on the market. In addition, she was also able to recommend insurance companies, closing attorneys and banks. I highly recommend Priscilla Stolba of Priscilla Stolba Real Estate as a real estate agent and buyer’s broker.
Priscilla is an amazing realtor that has worked with our family as we acquired our Cape home. We have purchased and sold properties with her and she is tireless in her representation of her clients. Her communication skills are the best I have ever seen--she uses telephone, text, email and ensures that everyone knows what is going on. Her work product is exceptional and her years of experience come in very handy. She knows the value of properties, and is a known entity with other realtors in the market. She knows the Mashpee/Falmouth market like the back of her hand and is so easy and pleasant to work with. I would not buy a home without her---she is that good and that easy to work with.
Specializes in
Also offers
Service area
Languages
Ownership
Certified attributes are verified against the public registry. Others are the business's own statement.
1 change recorded — last scanned Aug 27, 2026.
Repeat clients4.3
Out-of-state buyer support4.1
First-time buyer praise3.7
Registry-verified MA broker licenseNot yet rated