Verified record
Best Price Paving is a small driveway sealcoating and asphalt operation run by an owner reviewers call Bill, working the Natick and Metrowest area. Its BBB file is thin — opened April 2025, one employee, no street address, no owner named, with an A- grade that BBB attributes solely to length of time in operation. The record around this listing is dominated by December 2025 local-news investigations: NBC Boston and Boston 25 reported that William "Bill" Pusateri, arrested with outstanding warrants after scamming customers — including an elderly woman who paid $4,000 cash for driveway paving that was never done — told customers he was with "Priority 1 Paving" out of Dedham or "Best Price Paving" in the Sharon area. This listing's own review record carries the same shape: a June 2025 one-star says a deposit was taken, the job was delayed for weeks, another job was simply abandoned and the phone put out of service — and calls the listing's positive reviews fake — while a November 2025 one-star describes two jobs from "Bill" marked by weeks of delays, shifting personal excuses, and an improperly completed front step. Against that, seventeen five-star reviews from June–September 2025 praise fast, inexpensive sealcoating and crack-filling by Bill and his crew across several neighborhoods. Given the fraud coverage naming this business name and the deposit-and-disappear accounts on this very listing, the 4.4-star Google average cannot be read as a trust signal, and this profile should be treated as a warning record rather than a recommendation.
“According to the documents, Pusateri told customers he was with “Priority 1 Paving” or “Best Price Paving.””
“According to the documents, Pusateri told customers he was with “Priority 1 Paving” or “Best Price Paving.””
“Some of the company names he used included Priority 1 Paving out of Dedham and Best Price Paving in the Sharon area and is working with others yet to be identified.”
DON'T DO BUSINESS WITH BILL. "Bill", seemed like an honest person, but now I can say he's not a good business man. He did two jobs at our home, sealant on the driveway and "fix" a front step. The first job (the driveway) was completed with many delays and excuses. The second job (the front step), was not completed properly. Both times his excuses for the delays and poor communication were: "someone stole my phone and all my money", "I was hacked, my business was hacked, they took all my money", he also told us a whole tale of the women he dated and how they probably stole his money and hacked him. Truly, very awkward conversations, not welcomed and just inappropriate. Maybe he's just very "down to earth", but it just felt like random excuses were presented to justify his delays. He did mention that he had split with his business partner, so this review is for the person who goes by "Bill", he gave us a "Best Price Paving" card, and this is how I found this page. For those out there who encounter this man, beware. Update: see pictures. This is “Bill”
All the driveways in my neighborhood have been rejuvenated by Best Price Paving. All are happy with the quality job done promptly and professionally, worth giving them a call for your job.
Mike and his crew did a great job power washing my brick steps and filling in some cracks with mortar and seal coating and filling in cracks on my driveway. He gave me a very fair price and did the work on time, I would highly recommend this company.
Good price, excellent job and easy to work with.
Really good job. No complaints at all.
Specializes in
Also offers
Languages
Added 20 new comments, added 24 new photos
Hardscape construction4.3