Verified record
Melanie Cauchon runs My Cape Cod Realty from Brewster, working as a buyer's and seller's agent across Cape Cod. Google reviewers rate her 5 stars from 56 ratings, and the 37 written reviews on file, dating from 2021 through 2026, tell a remarkably consistent story. Clients repeatedly describe her as deeply hands-on through the whole transaction, researching anything she isn't sure of and responding to questions even late in the evening. Several came back to her a second time: one buyer who purchased a cottage through her fifteen years ago hired her again to sell it, praising how organized and on top of follow-up she stayed; another used her for two separate purchases handled in quick succession, including help finding an attorney who could close fast. A recent review describes her guiding a family through the sale of a late parent's home complicated by multiple encroachment issues, referring them to resources to help resolve them. An older 2021 review recounts a months-long, exacting search — a house with enough land for a remodel, under $300,000, in one of three specific towns — that ended in exactly the home the buyers wanted. Many of the transactions in her reviews are second-home purchases: reviewers describe buying summer places, a waterfront cottage, and a Cape Cod RV, and consistently credit her with the kind of town-by-town, pricing-level knowledge that made those decisions easier for buyers who weren't local. The one review that breaks from the pattern, from December 2021 and rated three stars, described a mixed experience: the seller praised her staging and a quick turnaround from listing to offer, but said the accepted price came in $5,000 under asking and that she was contacted again afterward about further concessions. Anyone considering My Cape Cod Realty should weigh the overwhelming, detailed, multi-year run of five-star transactions — including repeat clients and complex estate sales — against that single seller's account of price pressure after a deal was struck, and ask directly how offer and concession negotiations are typically handled.
Pleasant, kind and informative . Melanie is very informative and familiar with the real estate market. She guided us through the purchasing process and was in constant contact by email and phone calls. We had plenty of questions and her kindness and patience was greatly appreciated. Melanie is a quality person and you want her to be on your side during a purchase.
Working with Melanie Cauchon was a genuinely great experience from start to finish. Communication was excellent throughout — quick responses, clear updates at every stage, and always happy to answer questions no matter how small. It was obvious I was dealing with someone who truly knew the local RV market; her insights on pricing and timing gave me real confidence in our decisions. When it came to negotiations, she was sharp and strategic, advocating for my interests while keeping things professional and level-headed. On top of all that, she carried themselves with real professionalism the whole way through — organized, punctual, and always prepared. Highly recommend to anyone buying or selling a home.
Melanie did an amazing job helping us purchase a place. She was highly efficient and organized. She was friendly, kind, and incredibly resourceful! Highly recommend her.
Melanie was phenomenal in helping us with our summer place purchase! Melanie has vast knowledge in the location we purchased, which was apparant when she was working with my husband and me. She was responsive when we reached out to her and she processed paperwork quickly and efficiently. I would highly recommend Melanie in the purchase of your future home!
A Wonderful Experience Looking for a New Home Mélanie Cauchon is really the best - as a person and a real estate agent. She knows every inch of the area where I wanted to find a home and really understood and focused on what I was looking for. Her knowledge of legal and financial issues concerning the purchase of property was eye-opener and invaluable to me. Mélanie’s professionalism is without question - always prompt to return calls and answer questions, and she has a sharp eye to notice problems in a property that need to be addressed or avoided. She always came to appointments with detailed printouts and photos of the properties for me to keep and would provide me with more information if I asked. She is understanding and patient. When I became overwhelmed by all that is entailed between the offering and the closing of a home, I always felt that Mélanie was looking out for me - above and beyond what I would have expected. My trust in her is 100%. I often told her that if 5 stars is considered top rating, she deserves far more than that. If I must move again, I will return to Mélanie Cauchon. Posted by Elizabeth W. (Buyer) on 02 Feb 2026
Specializes in
Also offers
Languages
2 changes recorded — last scanned Aug 23, 2026.
Above-asking sales4.3
Sold within days of listing4.3
Verified licenseNot yet rated