Craigville Realty, Inc.

Craigville Realty, Inc. is a real estate brokerage based at 648 Craigville Beach Road in Centerville, on Cape Cod, that lists and sells homes through the Cape Cod MLS while also managing roughly 200 privately-owned vacation rental homes and cottages around Centerville, Hyannis, Hyannis Port and Osterville. The company states it has been serving Cape Cod vacationers for more than 50 years, and its Massachusetts real estate broker license (9590-RE-C) is active and registry-verified under the Craigville Realty, Inc. name. Beyond the license, the available track record is thin and troubled. A 2024 review describes a home purchase in which the seller's bankruptcy was allegedly not disclosed before an offer was accepted, followed by repeated delays and a purchase-and-sale violation; the reviewer also says items were removed from the house before closing and no keys were provided. A separate 2022 review alleges the owner, named as Martin, behaved disrespectfully and inappropriately toward the reviewer. No positive first-hand account of a transaction with Craigville Realty is on file to weigh against these. Anyone considering Craigville Realty for a sale, purchase, or vacation rental booking should ask directly about how the brokerage handles seller disclosures and closing logistics, and should feel free to raise the conduct concerns above before engaging. The firm's long-standing presence and active license are real, but with only a handful of reviews on record — one unrelated to real estate entirely — there isn't enough positive history here to offset the two detailed complaints.