Verified record
James Dunlay's Westwood, Massachusetts carpentry business draws two very different reactions depending on the platform. On Angi, five-star reviewers call his finish work meticulous and exacting; on BuildZoom, two reviewers describe a no-show and a job that never started. He works under the name Dunlay Renovation & Construction and is typically hired for finish carpentry — trim, built-ins, framing, decks, and stairs; a January 2025 Thumbtack review says the outdoor stairs he built for a customer "came out great." The detail behind the Angi praise, written in 2017 and 2018, is specific: one reviewer described him raising the height of a basement ceiling and framing trim around a door, another said he sank new deck posts and worked directly with the town on inspections, and several mentioned fair pricing — one recalled having to talk him into accepting a tip. A more recent Thumbtack review from December 2024 describes the same traits: polite, responsive, punctual, and fair on price. BuildZoom's two reviews tell a different story, and they're the reason that platform's average sits at 1 out of 5. A 2021 review says he didn't show up as scheduled, later called to say he was on his way, and became irate when told he wasn't expected after not returning calls. An earlier, 2016 review says he was responsive at first and gave a very low estimate, but the start date kept changing and the work never began — the reviewer called it a scam. BuildZoom lists a Massachusetts home improvement contractor registration, #179558, issued in October 2025, for the business, and separately a construction supervisor number, #CS-107619 — both worth checking directly against the state registry before signing anything. The Better Business Bureau gives the business an A+ rating, though it is not a BBB-accredited business. Angi's profile lists 11 years of experience; Thumbtack's lists 15. Given how far apart the praise and the complaints sit, this is a contractor worth pinning down on a firm start date and a written schedule before booking anything beyond a small job, and worth confirming is currently licensed before signing.
Jim built outdoor stairs for us and they came out great.
Very polite, extremely easy to work with, and very responsive! Sweet personality, easy to work with and hardworking. He was meticulous and detailed in his work - very professional and punctual. He was also very fair in his pricing. I will be hiring him again for future projects!
We had the exact same experience. He did not show up as scheduled. One day he randomly called to say he would be starting in a few minutes. When he was told we were not expecting him as he had not returned telephone calls. He was advised to come in an hour. He became irate and decided he would not do the work. This happened after waiting for him for a month. He completely lacks follow through. He is NOT trustworthy!
If you are looking for an independent carpenter and craftsman who is skilled, meticulous, and easy to work with, Jim is your man. He did various carpentry projects around the house including raising the height of the ceiling to the basement, trim around the door, residing of a shed, and reattaching a railing. Some plastering needed to be done in the stairway, so he brought in his own professional to be sure to be it was done perfectly I will definitely use him again. The other reviews on Jim were my experience. Thank Jim!
Jim was a total professional, from both a workmanship perspective and a communication perspective. He was thorough and diligent and exacting, and it's clear how much pride he takes in the final product and how important the details are to him. I would hire him again in a second and recommend him to others without hesitation.
Specializes in
Also offers
Languages
1 change recorded — last scanned Sep 9, 2026.
Typical Greater Boston range for this kind of work, from regional averages — not a quote from James Dunlay. Use it to sanity-check bids, then get the real number in writing.
A typical single-level deck is 12×16 — about 200 sq ft.
Estimated range
$7,750 – $14,500
Typical carpentry project around $11,100
Came back to fix deck stairs years later5.0
Decks and porches5.0
Custom sheds5.0