Checked Nov 18, 4:41 PM
Past 7 days · Price per gallon
Surner Heating is a heating, air conditioning and fuel company whose stated service area includes Amherst; a recent customer called at 8am on a Monday for AC service, and Ron came by 9 and fixed a bad coil. The company describes itself as a Western Massachusetts fuel dealer and HVAC contractor that delivers heating oil, Bioheat fuel and propane and installs, maintains and repairs heating and air conditioning systems in Hampshire and Franklin Counties. It says it began as College Oil Company in 1963, when founder Ben Surner made his first delivery in a 1946 GMC oil truck, and that Susan Surner took over as sole owner in 2021. The Massachusetts Supplier Diversity Office lists Surner Heating Company, Inc. as a certified Women Business Enterprise, certification 20220161, expiring in 2028. On Google it holds 4.4 stars from 149 ratings, and the BBB gives it an A+. A recent customer wrote that Kareem, Joe, Keith and Leigh put in a new furnace and water tank for the house and called the work clean, professional and timely. A recent customer said Kareem, Ed and Edson removed the old oil tanks and installed a new one with new filler pipes and connections to the boiler. A recent customer thanked Joe, Kareem and Keith for a mini-split install. A recent customer lost hot water on a Sunday evening, called at 9 on Monday and had it repaired a few hours later, with Ron as the technician. A recent customer wrote that Leigh serviced a water heater and whole-house heat pump and pointed out mice or chipmunks leaving acorn refuse in the outdoor heat pump unit. A 2026 customer who said a former propane service had let them run out twice in the winter in two years called Surner and had a new 1000-gallon tank installed the same day and filled shortly after. A 2023 customer said Joe came out first to recommend the best fit for the home, then Joe, Victor, Rich and Gabe arrived at the scheduled time to replace the furnace and oil tank, did a thorough clean-up and went over the new furnace. A 2023 customer whose 33-year-old heating system failed said Surner designed a new, more efficient system that Joe and John installed in less than two days. In a 2022 review, a customer said Lee arrived within the hour for a fast drip from a baseboard leak late on a Friday, made a temporary fix until he could get the part, and was back Monday afternoon with the problem solved. A 2023 customer whose 24-year-old furnace was replaced said they were disappointed it had failed a few weeks after a complete tune-up by Surner. A recent 1-star customer wrote that after an oil delivery was canceled, the company kept delivering and billing the credit card it had, and called its customer service horrific. A 2026 customer said oil was delivered after they called weeks in advance to cancel and that the company would not give a refund; in a 2026 edit, that reviewer wrote that its first instinct was to deny and dismiss. A 2023 review from a house of six college students in Amherst complained of high propane delivery fees, credit card charges they could not explain, a lack of communication and no invoices. A 2023 customer said Surner charged $159 just to come out to a mini-split AC unit, misdiagnosed the problem and never got back with an estimate. A 2021 customer said they were charged almost $500 and that the value of the part was tripled and brushed off as labor, travel and experience. A 2022 customer said they had tried for 15 minutes to get someone on the phone and were refused emergency service even though their tanks were Surner tanks. A 2022 customer who asked why Surner's oil price was higher said the woman who answered replied "do you want it or no." A 2022 customer wrote that around 2013 the company filled the tank with about 15 to 20 gallons when they had asked it to use only the remainder of a Fuel Assistance budget, was rude and threatened court over the bill, and later sent trucks to pump the oil back out. A 2023 r/massachusetts post was titled "Fearmongering and lies from Surner Heating (heating oil company) about Clean Heat Standard." A 2023 r/massachusetts commenter wrote that a Surner letter scared a family member into thinking she would be forced into debt to replace a gas furnace she had just replaced, due to the state's Clean Heat Standard.
“This letter from Surner Heating scared my family member into thinking she was about to be forced to go into debt to replace her gas furnace (which she just replaced recently) due to the state's Clean Heat Standard.”
“Fearmongering and lies from Surner Heating (heating oil company) about Clean Heat Standard”
Ron responded within hours after I placed a call to Surner. He came to our house and repaired the problem with our air conditioner. He was polite, fast and efficient.
Leigh was a fantastic service technician. At our yearly cleaning, he gave us some great suggestions to improve our system, explaining them well and thoroughly. He was very personable and helpful.
Levi came by for a cleaning, he was prompt, pleasant, and professional. I asked about items to keep an eye on since I recently moved in. His response was reasonable and clear. It’s good to know I can call on Surner with my heating system needs.
Did an excellent job. Very friendly and professional.
Surner technician Leigh serviced my water heater and whole-house heat pump on Friday. He did a thorough professional job, and he pointed out a couple of things that I needed to attend to (e.g., mice or chipmunks leaving acorn refuse in my outdoor heat pump unit). His excellent work is going to get us through the weather extremes I'm sure are coming our way.
Specializes in
Also offers
Service area
2 changes recorded — last scanned Aug 7, 2026.
Typical Greater Boston range for this kind of work, from regional averages — not a quote from Surner Heating Co., Inc.. Use it to sanity-check bids, then get the real number in writing.
Estimated range
$5,000 – $11,400
Typical HVAC project around $8,200
Most homes have a 275-gallon tank, and a delivery usually fills whatever is left in it — so pick how many gallons you need. The total is before any fees or taxes.
Estimated total
$1,539.73
275 gal at $5.599, before fees
Languages
Languages
Ownership
Certified attributes are verified against the public registry. Others are the business's own statement.
Ownership
Certified attributes are verified against the public registry. Others are the business's own statement.
State-verified HVAC license2.9