Custom Crafted Homes

Custom Crafted Homes has built and renovated homes across Cape Cod for years, and the thing that stands out across a decade of reviews is how many customers come back — several say explicitly this wasn't their first project with the company, and won't be their last. Based in South Dennis and run by owner Jeff Baroni, the company describes itself as a family business working all 15 Cape Cod towns; its own site traces the operation back to 1974, while BBB's registration records show the business was started in 2000 — worth asking which era of the company applies to the crew you'd actually be hiring. The written record runs deep and consistent: 26 reviews from 2015 through 2025 across Angi, BBB, and local press, and the praise rarely wavers — Angi shows 45 ratings at 4.9 stars, and BBB gives the company an A+. What repeats across the reviews is specificity: a 2020 customer describes a full remodel where CCH stepped in after another contractor left the job behind schedule and under-built, handling a to-the-studs bathroom and kitchen renovation, a fireplace replacement, new siding, HVAC, and more. A 2017 review describes Jeff and his crew replacing rotting trim and a disintegrating sunroom frame at an elderly homeowner's house in Yarmouth Port, working around a tight budget and treating her with evident care. Deck work comes up often too — a 2018 review describes a wooden deck rebuilt in AZEK, and a 2015 review describes an existing deck torn down and replaced with a four-season addition. There isn't much to flag on the work itself: even the lower-rated reviews on file (a few 4.5s) describe projects finished on budget and on time, without a substantive complaint attached. The one thing worth asking about directly is that founding-date gap between the company's own history page and its official registration — a decades-old family trade doesn't always map cleanly onto a single legal business start date, but it's a fair question before signing a contract. Custom Crafted Homes reads like a strong call for a full kitchen or bathroom renovation, a home addition, or a larger multi-trade remodel on Cape Cod — the kind of project where having one crew handle framing, trim, and finish work in-house matters. Confirm current crew availability and timeline before booking, since a few reviews describe projects that ran longer than initially hoped.