Extreme Make Over Custom Home Repair Handyman Services

Extreme Make Over Custom Home Repair Handyman Services is a Pelham, New Hampshire operation run by John Leahy, with a review history that runs deep and stays remarkably consistent: 55 reviews since 2013 across Google, Angi and HomeAdvisor, and the overwhelming majority land at five stars. What people hire him for varies widely — a new entry door, a cathedral-ceiling breezeway rebuild, a water-damaged hardwood floor, a bathroom retiled down to the studs — and reviewers keep circling back to the same traits no matter the job: he shows up when he says he will, walks through the plan before starting, and gives an estimate that holds. One customer who has used him across several homes over 15 years calls him reliable and knowledgeable; another, describing a breezeway and cathedral-ceiling rebuild, praised a detailed quote and an on-time, on-budget finish. The written reviews show real range beyond small repairs: luxury vinyl plank and hardwood floor work, interior and exterior door installation, drywall and tile on full bathroom renovations, granite countertops and backsplashes in kitchens, and smaller jobs like hanging a stove hood or swapping a slider door. HomeAdvisor and Angi both put him at 4.8★ from 99 ratings; Google shows both 5★ from 31 ratings and 4★ from 7 — two listings for the same business rather than a split verdict, since the written reviews on both are almost entirely five-star. It isn't a spotless record — one 2018 Angi review called the work unsatisfactory, with no detail on what went wrong, a lone outlier against dozens of specific, detailed five-star accounts spanning eight years. Otherwise the pattern holds steady from 2018 through this year: the same responsiveness and clean, thorough work keeps coming up. For anything from a stuck door to a full bathroom or kitchen refresh, this reads as a dependable call — the kind of contractor several reviewers say they've come back to for a second and third project. Worth confirming scope and timeline up front for a larger job, since the reviews describe John working directly on-site alongside a small, named crew rather than a larger company.