Verified record
On its Houzz profile, Hilltop Roofing describes itself as a roofing contractor in Maine. Its BBB grade is A+. In a 2011 Angi review, a customer said they called about eight contractors and owner Justin Gibbons was the first to respond; within two days he drove over to evaluate the job, then provided an estimate within 48 hours. That 2011 customer wrote that Hilltop was the only company to give an estimate for all three roof styles they were comparing โ asphalt shingles, exposed fastener metal and standing seam metal โ and that there was no pressure from him to go with standing seam, the most expensive option. The 2011 reviewer also wrote that a repair to the roof deck was required after stripping and they were not charged for it. In that 2011 review, the customer said Justin repaired a very small cut in a custom window screen shortly after the job, special ordering the screen material from the window manufacturer. A 2016 Angi customer said Justin's team also removed an old brick chimney in the middle of the house, cleaned the site afterwards and clearly explained the work. A 2013 Angi customer said they had a lot more choices than with other contractors as far as what they wanted.
Justin and his Hilltop Roofing team were very easy to work with. They had competitive pricing and charged a clear, fair price for any add'l work. We had his team also remove an old brick chimney in the middle of the house. They did a thorough job, cleaned the site afterwards and clearly explained the work provided. Highly recommend working with Hilltop Roofing.
Yes, I recommend this
Working with them was very good. They were very nice and very helpful. I like that we had a lot more choices than other contractors as far as what we wanted and they are more understanding about stuff.
Called about eight contractors to obtain an estimate. Hilltop owner Justin Gibbons was the first to respond. Within two days, he drove over and personally evaluated the job and then provided an estimate within 48 hours. His price was very competitive with the others and included work that others did not (e.g., replacing mating trim board on porch, guards above/to protect vent stack,etc...). We were comparing costs of going with asphalt shingles, exposed fastener metal or standing seam metal. This was the only company to provide an estimate for all three and, with each came an ample amount of written information and handouts describing the product, warranty, colors, etc... While a standing seam metal roof was the most expensive of all options, there was absolutely no pressure from him to go that route. The estimate for the exposed fastener style roof was the most appealling to us. There was only one estimate for that style roof that was less than Hilltop's, but it did not come with the same contractor warranty, product information or extra work described above. Hilltop also had the lowest rate for any unforeseen additional work that might be encountered. In fact, a repair to the roof deck was required after stripping, and we were not charged for it. In addition, a very small cut was found in a custom window screen shortly after the job, and Justin was quick to repair the screen for us, going the extra mile by special ordering the screen material from the window manufacturer to assure a perfect match of mesh size and color.
Specializes in
Also offers
Languages
1 change recorded โ last scanned Oct 4, 2026.
Typical Greater Boston range for this kind of work, from regional averages โ not a quote from HILLTOP ROOFING. Use it to sanity-check bids, then get the real number in writing.
A square is 100 sq ft of roof surface โ bigger than the floor plan because of pitch and overhangs.
Estimated range
$9,000 โ $18,600
Typical roofing project around $13,800
Seven skylight replacements in one day5.0
Answers in a storm5.0
Detailed craftsmanship5.0