Order oilDirect from the company
Pricing not available
We couldn't find a price when we last checked. Call or visit their website for a quote.
"We use Mitchell Fuel out of South Windsor. They're great," a commenter wrote in a recent r/Connecticut thread. Mitchell Fuel Company says it is a family-owned business that has served South Windsor and Bolton since 1957 with heating and air conditioning services. A recent customer from Manchester said that when their oil tank developed a significant leak, Mitchell Fuel responded quickly and a replacement tank was installed and working the very next day, and the crew's cleanup afterward was thorough. That customer said they had relied on the company for nearly twenty years for oil delivery and furnace maintenance. A 2026 customer said a driver brought oil on a same-day order after a rough experience with a competitor that morning, and that the driver was kind and polite. In a 2022 review, a customer said they and their brother had used Mitchell Fuel for oil delivery, boiler service and a boiler install at four properties for 15+ years, and that techs explained what they were repairing or replacing and why. A 2024 customer said they had used Mitchell Fuel for 6 years without a problem with deliveries and found Marie helpful. A recent customer said Sonya was very nice to them about an issue with billing and service costs, and that it was resolved. A recent customer said prices were too high, that they were yelled at when they called at a busy time, and that the receptionist, Maria, was unprofessional. A 2026 customer said an oil delivery took about 14 days to arrive, that they ran out of oil over a weekend, and that Sonia finally made the delivery happen before they switched companies. In a 2022 review, a customer said a Daikin heat pump installed at their mother's house in 2020 had problems, that 2021 passed without one visit from Mitchell while temperatures fluctuated, and that a Daikin rep talked them through a fix on the wall remote. A 2021 customer said that after a delivery person sent photos to the office, Mitchell said the water heater tank needed replacing and declined to send a technician to confirm; a different company replaced a pump instead. A 2023 customer said a customer service rep told them to go elsewhere if they were unhappy. Connecticut lists its S1 heating and cooling contractor licence, HTG.0409009-S1, as active, held by Mitchell Fuel Co Inc.
“We use Mitchell Fuel out of South Windsor. They're great.”
Sonya was very nice to me about an issue we had with billing and service costs. We resolved the issue satisfactorily-,I appreciate this greartly.
We are writing this review to express our profound gratitude for the exemplary service we recently received from Mitchell Fuel. In a moment of considerable stress, when our less than nine-year-old oil tank (installed by another company) unexpectedly developed a significant leak, the team’s response was nothing short of outstanding. We were incredibly impressed by their swift action. Mitchell Fuel responded to our urgent call with remarkable speed, and to our immense relief, a replacement tank was expertly installed and fully operational the very next day. This rapid mobilization and efficient resolution not only mitigated potential further damage but also alleviated a great deal of anxiety for us. The crew dispatched to our home demonstrated exceptional professionalism and expertise throughout the entire process. Their meticulous cleanup after the tank replacement was thorough, and their reassuring demeanor during what was a very stressful time for us was truly commendable. They handled every aspect with precision and care. As customers who have relied on Mitchell Fuel for nearly twenty years for our oil delivery and furnace maintenance, we have consistently valued your reliability and high standards. This latest experience only solidifies our trust and confidence in their services. For anyone in search of a truly comprehensive and dependable full-service oil company that delivers prompt, expert solutions and genuine customer care, we wholeheartedly and unreservedly recommend Mitchell Fuel. Terry & Linda W Manchester, Ct Sent from Yahoo Mail for iPhone
Prices are too high and the customer service is very poor. When you call and they’re busy, they don’t politely ask you to wait or call back they just yell at you like you’re supposed to know their schedule. The receptionist, Maria, was completely unprofessional.
If you want a headache and to be disrespected by a receptionist named Maria, then this is the right company to deal with. She will treat you like a child and yell at you for no reason. There was a delivery scheduled for oil that I was not aware of and I did not place an order for. At the time, there was snow on the grass where the oil tank is located. Maria called me and was yelling, saying they couldn’t deliver the oil because of the snow and that she had a business to run. I politely explained that I understood the situation and that I would clear the snow to make room for the delivery. I also told her there was no rush since I still had oil in the tank, and I wasn’t even aware that a delivery had been scheduled in the first place. About a week later, after the snow was cleared and there was no issue with access, I called again. Maria answered with the same attitude and said the oil would be delivered the next day. However, another week passed and I still did not receive the delivery. In total, I waited about 14 days, and over the weekend I completely ran out of oil. When I called again, the delivery driver said he would speak to Maria and get back to me since it was after hours, but I never heard back from anyone.I have been a customer for a long time and previously dealt with Sonia, who was always professional and helpful and always went above and beyond for customers. Unfortunately, since Maria took over, the service and attitude have been very disappointing. After more than two weeks, I spoke with Sonia and she finally made the delivery happen. However, at that point I had already decided that I did not want to deal with Maria anymore. I chose to switch to a different company that treats customers with respect. Maria should not be working in customer service if she does not know how to speak to people properly.
The guy who came and brought oil on a same day order was a God send. We had a very rough experience with a competitor earlier this morning and they made the delivery quick and easy. $.40 cheaper/gallon than we were charged by the other company as well. Most importantly, the delivery driver was very kind and polite so they’ve got our business.
Specializes in
Also offers
Service area
Languages
Ownership
Certified attributes are verified against the public registry. Others are the business's own statement.
1 change recorded — last scanned Oct 8, 2026.
Oil tank replaced in just 4 hours5.0