The Fiberglass Gutter Company

The Fiberglass Gutter Company doesn't just install gutters — it molds its own by hand in Pembroke, built to look like traditional wood without the rot or repainting wood eventually needs. The company says it's been family-owned since its 2013 founding, and its niche has drawn outside notice: a 2015 Fine Homebuilding piece pointed readers to it by name as the source for that wood look without the wood upkeep. Customer reviews are thin so far — Google shows just a handful of ratings averaging 3.7★, and the one review on file, from late 2025, put it simply: "the whole team were great." What carries more weight is the company's standing with the Better Business Bureau, where it's accredited with an A+ rating and no complaints filed. The BBB profile lists President James McGill running a 24-person operation focused on wood-replica fiberglass gutters for historic renovations and new construction. Worth asking about before booking: a 2023 OSHA inspection turned up three citations and $5,322.80 in proposed penalties. Public inspection records don't say whether that's been resolved, so it's worth raising directly with the company. This is a good fit for anyone restoring an older home who wants gutters that read as wood without the upkeep, or a new-construction project chasing the same look. Given how thin the online review trail still is, ask for a couple of recent local references before signing on.